8 Challenges in Creating a Crypto Exchange

Learn the Common Pitfalls That Occur When Creating This Exchange.

Launching a crypto exchange offers opportunities but comes with significant challenges. As the market grows, so does the complexity, from technical infrastructure to financial regulations.

Building a successful platform demands robust security, sufficient liquidity, strict compliance, and strong user trust, each presenting its own set of challenges.

This article outlines eight challenges you’ll encounter when creating a crypto exchange.

1. Navigating Regulatory Compliance in Creating a Crypto Exchange

The fragmentation of the regulatory environment presents significant challenges in creating a crypto exchange. Countries and regions implement a wide array of approaches, shaped by differing economic priorities, risk perceptions and the evolving nature of digital assets.

Key Global Regulatory Frameworks

Financial Action Task Force (FATF) Standards

The FATF’s “Travel Rule” mandates that Virtual Asset Service Providers (VASPs), including crypto exchanges, transmit certain information about senders and recipients in crypto transactions to combat money laundering and terrorism financing. In 2025, FATF revised the Travel Rule to cover all crypto payments, not just large transactions, expanding the compliance footprint for exchanges globally.

Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) in Europe

MiCA is the world’s first comprehensive, pan-national crypto law. It sets unified requirements on licensing, transparency, consumer protection, reserve management for stablecoins and anti-market abuse controls. MiCA applies to all crypto service providers, including exchanges, wallet providers and stablecoin issuers operating or serving clients in the EU.

United States Approach

The U.S. regulatory system remains fragmented. However, progress on federal clarity has been made with the introduction of the STABLE Act and GENIUS Act, focusing on stablecoin oversight and broader digital asset regulatory clarity, respectively.

KYC/AML Compliance

Know Your Customer (KYC) and Anti-Money Laundering (AML) controls are vital for preventing fraud, identity theft and illicit flows. Exchanges must implement robust KYC/AML procedures to comply with global standards while balancing user experience. This includes:

• Incorporating tiered verification levels based on transaction volumes
• Using AI-powered verification systems for quick document processing
• Integrating with specialised KYC/AML service providers

Strategies for Compliance

To navigate this complex regulatory environment, crypto exchanges should consider the following strategies:

1. Partner with legal experts specialising in crypto regulation to stay updated on changes and requirements across jurisdictions.
2. Implement modular compliance approaches that can adapt to different jurisdictional requirements, allowing for flexibility in global operations.
3. Engage in proactive dialogue with regulators to help shape future regulations and demonstrate commitment to compliance.
4. Invest in regtech solutions that automate compliance processes and stay updated with regulatory changes, reducing the risk of non-compliance.
5. Establish robust internal governance structures and risk management policies to address vulnerabilities and prevent operational failures or fraud.

2. Providing Robust Security Measures

Developing robust security measures is one of the main challenges in creating a crypto exchange. As guardians of user funds, exchanges need layered defences to protect assets and earn trust.

Critical Security Measures

Cold storage is integral to exchange security. Keeping 90–95% of assets offline dramatically cuts theft risk during breaches. For example, Coinbase stores 98% of customer assets in cold storage, setting a gold standard for the industry.

Multi-factor authentication (MFA) provides the protection needed for exchange operations and user accounts. Leading exchanges now offer biometric authentication beyond traditional MFA approaches. This extra step stops unauthorised access even when passwords are compromised.

Address whitelisting adds another safety layer. By limiting withdrawals to pre-approved crypto addresses, exchanges protect against account takeovers.

Multi-signature wallets require multiple private keys to authorise transactions, eliminating single points of failure. This distributed approach guarantees no individual holds complete control over funds, guarding against external attacks and internal threats.

Building User Trust

Strong security directly builds user confidence and platform credibility. Exchanges with transparent security practices gain higher user trust. Coinbase’s approach, including AES-256 encryption for wallet private keys, has helped it maintain strong security despite being a prime target.

Incorporating Security Protocols

Regular security audits and penetration testing help find and fix vulnerabilities before attackers can exploit them. Advanced AI-driven fraud detection systems can also spot and block suspicious activities.

Many breaches happen through human error or social engineering. Training staff about security best practices and potential threats significantly reduces these risks.

While security breaches remain a major threat to exchanges, comprehensive security measures protect user assets and build trust for long-term success in the cryptocurrency market.

3. Achieving Sufficient Liquidity

Liquidity is integral to cryptocurrency exchange. It determines how easily assets can be bought or sold without causing significant price changes. For new exchanges, achieving sufficient liquidity represents one of the major challenges in creating a crypto exchange.

Liquidity plays a role in creating trading environments with tight bid-ask spreads and minimal slippage. According to Openware, “Liquidity management over a crypto exchange means creating adequate trading activity for assets that can be bought and sold with minimal impact on price.” High liquidity attracts more traders and investors, creating a virtuous cycle of increased trading activity and improved market efficiency.

Challenges Faced

New exchanges face specific challenges in building liquidity, particularly for less popular trading pairs. These challenges include:

1. Limited user base and trading volume
2. Competition from established exchanges
3. Difficulty in attracting market makers
4. Volatility in emerging cryptocurrencies

Strategies for Liquidity

To overcome these challenges and achieve sufficient liquidity, exchanges can use several strategies:

1. Professional market maker partnerships: Collaborating with specialised firms to provide continuous buy and sell orders, ensuring there’s always a counterparty for trades. These partnerships can increase order book depth and trading volume.
2. Automated Market Making (AMM): Incorporating AMM mechanisms, especially for less liquid pairs, can provide instant liquidity without relying on traditional order books. AMMs have become popular in decentralised exchanges and can be adapted for centralised platforms as well.
3. Liquidity pools: Creating or integrating with liquidity pools allows users to contribute assets and earn rewards, increasing overall liquidity. Openware explains that these pools can serve as a reserve in extreme market conditions when traders suddenly abandon the market.
4. Liquidity aggregation: Connecting to multiple liquidity sources through APIs can improve depth and reduce spreads. ChainUp suggests that aggregating liquidity from various providers can enhance overall market efficiency.
5. Incentive programs: Offering fee rebates or reward programs to incentivise traders and market makers. These incentives can attract high-frequency traders and increase overall trading volume.
6. Risk management: Implementing circuit breakers and other volatility control measures can help manage liquidity during extreme market conditions. Openware recommends temporarily halting trading in wild swings to give market makers time to rebuild liquidity and avoid disruptions driven by panic.
7. Marketplace models: Adopting marketplace models can facilitate liquidity by connecting buyers and sellers more efficiently, encouraging higher trading volumes.

4. Developing a Scalable and Reliable Platform

Building a scalable, reliable crypto exchange capable of handling high transaction volumes requires careful planning and technical expertise. Here’s what it takes to create a platform that performs under pressure.

Technical Requirements

• Cloud infrastructure: Services like AWS or Google Cloud provide flexible scaling without heavy upfront costs.
• Microservices architecture: Breaking the system into independent components simplifies scaling, maintenance and improves performance.
• High-performance trading engine: A fast, low-latency engine efficiently matches orders and handles large data volumes during peak activity.
• Database management: Scalable databases like Apache Cassandra or MongoDB manage user data and order books reliably, with data replication preventing loss from server failures.

Performance Challenges

• Peak trading times: Handle spikes with load balancing, caching and optimised database queries.
• Potential bottlenecks: Monitor for network delays, slow database operations, inefficient matching algorithms and limited API throughput.

Best Practices

• Comprehensive testing: Use unit, integration, load and security testing to identify issues early.
• Horizontal scaling: Add machines to scale flexibly and cost-effectively instead of upgrading hardware.
• Regular load testing: Simulate traffic spikes to ensure stability before real events.
• Redundancy planning: Use multiple data centres, failover systems, and maintain backups for critical services.

Trade-offs: Custom Solutions vs White-Label Platforms

• Custom builds offer control but require more time and expertise.
• White-label platforms enable faster launch but with less customisation.
• Choose based on your technical capabilities, resources and business goals.

5. Creating an Intuitive User Experience

A great user experience directly affects how people engage with your crypto exchange.

The main challenge in crypto exchange design is finding the balance between simplicity for newcomers and advanced tools for experienced traders.

Common UI/UX Pitfalls to Avoid

1. Cluttered interfaces that overwhelm users and drive them away
2. Skipping user testing across different groups, creating interfaces that miss actual needs
3. Inconsistent design elements and terminology that confuse users and damage trust
4. Ignoring accessibility, which excludes potential users and may break regulations

Design Recommendations

To create a user experience that works, consider these approaches:

1. Design layouts that guide users toward key actions with minimal friction. Use visual hierarchy to highlight what’s important.
2. Keep menus simple and logically organise related items so users don’t get lost.
3. Prioritise responsive design that works on all devices, especially mobile ones, where more trading happens daily.
4. Reveal advanced features gradually as users become more comfortable with your platform.
5. Weave learning resources naturally into the interface to help users understand complex concepts.

Emerging Trends in Crypto UX

1. AI technologies: Incorporate AI technologies that provide personalisation, customising experiences based on individual trading patterns and preferences, resulting in highly personalised user experiences.
2. Visual search technologies: Employ visual search technologies to the interface, allowing users to find and interact with assets more intuitively.
3. Gamification elements: To make crypto more engaging, incorporate gamification elements like achievement badges for completing security setups or educational modules.
4. Interactive content: Utilise shoppable content and other interactive elements to make the platform more engaging.
5. Community features: Develop features such as social trading or expert commentary that enrich the user experience.

6. Managing Operational Costs and Resources

Managing operational costs and resources is another challenge in creating a crypto exchange. Starting and running a crypto exchange requires smart financial planning. Here’s a breakdown of approximate costs and how to manage your resources wisely.

Forecasting Challenges

Predicting expenses accurately in this business is tough due to: constantly changing regulations and compliance requirements, security costs that shift in response to new threats, market conditions affecting liquidity needs and unpredictable growth patterns impacting infrastructure needs.

Cost Optimisation Strategies

1. MVP approach: Start with core features, then build out based on user feedback.
2. White-label solutions: Consider pre-built platforms to cut development time and costs, as many mid-tier exchanges have done.
3. Cloud infrastructure: Use scalable cloud hosting to avoid heavy upfront investment. Pay only for what you need as you grow.
4. Strategic outsourcing: Hire specialists for non-core functions like customer support or certain development tasks.
5. Open source tools: Use open-source modules for wallet integration or trading engines to save on development.
6. Phased marketing: Start with organic growth and partnerships before spending big on paid advertising.
7. Compliance partnerships: Team up with regtech firms to simplify compliance and reduce in-house legal costs.
8. Monetising fintech solutions: Explore diverse revenue streams such as transaction fees, premium services and partnerships as ways of monetising fintech solutions.
9. Subscription models: Implement subscription models to generate steady revenue and improve customer retention.

7. Establishing Trust and Reputation

Trust is highly important in cryptocurrency, given the industry’s history of hacks and scams. To build credibility, you need a multi-pronged approach covering security, transparency and communication.

Robust Security Measures

• Advanced private key management to protect user assets
• Multi-factor authentication to prevent unauthorised access
• End-to-end encryption for data protection
• Regular security audits and penetration testing

Debut Infotech suggests exchanges consider white-label solutions with built-in security for quick deployment while maintaining reliability.

Transparency and Accountability

Being open about operations builds lasting trust:

• Regular proof of reserves audits so users can verify that you hold their funds
• Clear reporting on asset holdings and operations
• Third-party audits to verify internal controls

Kanga Exchange notes that “transparency and trust in the cryptocurrency ecosystem are not only desirable values but also key factors influencing investment decisions and risk perception.”

Regulatory Compliance

Following regulations builds institutional credibility:

• Implementing thorough KYC and AML procedures
• Obtaining necessary licenses in operating jurisdictions
• Staying current with evolving requirements

Togggle explains that “establishing trust in DeFi and cryptocurrency exchanges hinges significantly on integrating comprehensive regulatory compliance, advanced KYC procedures and transparent user fund management.”

Crisis Management

How you handle problems shapes your reputation. Communicate quickly and honestly about incidents, have clear plans for compensating users if losses occur and bring in external auditors to assess damage and upgrade security after any breach.

Community Engagement

Building relationships with users strengthens trust. Provide clear educational resources about your platform, maintain responsive support channels, share regular updates on developments and create an active community through forums, social media and modern engagement methods.

8. Integrating Payment Solutions

Integrating payment solutions is also one of the challenges in creating a crypto exchange. The challenge comes from handling both traditional money and cryptocurrencies while keeping everything frictionless for users.

Payment Integration Challenges

Complex integration requirements: You’ll need systems that handle blockchain transactions alongside traditional banking. This demands expertise in both cryptocurrency protocols and conventional payment systems.

Regulatory compliance: Different countries have wildly different rules about crypto payments, creating a complex compliance puzzle.

Market volatility: Crypto price swings can create settlement risks and potential losses during transaction processing.

Technical barriers for users: Many people struggle with crypto payment basics. Setting up wallets, understanding fees and dealing with blockchain confirmations can overwhelm non-technical users.

Impact on User Experience

How well your payment system works directly affects user satisfaction. Smooth payment processes reduce friction and keep users happy, reliable money handling builds trust in your platform and simple processes improve user retention and engagement.

Solutions for Payment Processing

Specialised payment processors: Partner with crypto payment services that offer ready-made APIs and developer tools. These typically provide comprehensive documentation and testing environments for smooth integration.

Modular payment architecture: Build a flexible system that can adapt to new cryptocurrencies and payment methods without needing complete rebuilds. This flexibility also allows for the implementation of alternative pricing strategies, such as subscription models or pay-per-use, to cater to different user preferences.

Multiple payment options: Offer various payment methods to match different user preferences, like bank transfers, the ability to accept card payments and different cryptocurrencies.

Real-time transaction status: Give clear, immediate feedback on transaction status, including blockchain confirmations and processing updates.

Automated compliance tools: Use regtech solutions that automate KYC/AML processes, maintain adherence to relevant compliance codes and stay current with regulatory changes.

The Path Forward for Exchange Development

Building a successful crypto exchange means tackling challenges like regulations, security, liquidity, scalable technology, user experience, cost control and payment integration. Navigating fragmented regulations requires expert legal guidance. Managing costs through cloud infrastructure and phased development supports growth. Transparency and strong payment systems connecting traditional finance and crypto are integral.

Rapyd’s all-in-one platform provides a single integration to accept payments, send payouts and create multi-currency business accounts. Trusted by 250,000+ merchants and a top Visa and Mastercard acquirer, Rapyd supports 900+ payment methods, instant payouts, bank transfers and 120+ currencies.

Ready for the last payment solution you’ll need? Get Started with Rapyd today.